If You Build It, Recruits Will Come: NESCAC Baseball Field Power Rankings
It’s time for another unorthodox power ranking. Who doesn’t like controversy, right? The NESCAC is home to some very nice baseball fields and some not so nice ones, but we’re starting to see a new wrinkle when it comes to judging a team’s field: artificial turf. These days more and more schools are installing some very impressive turf facilities, so that puts competing schools in a tough position. It’ll be interesting to see which school is next on the list, because Colby, Hamilton, and Trinity have started the movement towards the artificial surface. I’m all for “purity of the game” or whatever skeptics say, but when it’s still snowing in April you start to care less about what you’re playing on and more about actually playing. Anyways, let’s take a look at the finest diamonds across the NESCAC:
Work to do…
- Bowdoin
Pickard Diamond
What you see is what you get with Pickard Diamond. Nothing exciting, just a traditional grass baseball field with average, run of the mill wood dugouts. Like their football field, it’s a bit inaccessible, meaning that only the most dedicated fans make it out to games. For the fans that do, you better bring chairs with you, because there isn’t any place to sit. On a nice day this ballpark can look as good as any with its beautiful surrounding scenery, but sadly those nice days are numbered when you’re located in Maine. I can’t imagine the Polar Bears rely on their field as a recruiting tool.
- Middlebury
Forbes Field
Midd is known for pouring money into top notch, state of the art athletic facilities such as their beautiful indoor turf facility. Their baseball field must not have made the budget because it’s definitely not on par with everything else they have to offer. Not to say that the field itself is exceptionally poor, but like Bowdoin, it’s pretty much your average diamond. It doesn’t help that the field is a bit of a walk from the gym and from the rest of campus, making it a bit inconvenient to access. I wouldn’t be surprised if the Panthers were the next team to go turf in order to keep up with the rest of the league.
- Bates
Leahey Field
The Bobcats boast another remarkably average field. The fact that it’s grass is becoming increasingly frustrating as the Maine weather delays the season even more while peer schools get under way. What it has going for it is a nice central location that naturally yields decent crowds of people stopping by on their way from place to place. Having no seating behind home plate is a tough look, but the seating up each foul line does a good enough job for fans. If you’re lucky, the aroma from chicken nugget day at Commons will waft across the street, only enhancing the ballpark experience.
Not bad…
- Williams
Bobby Coombs Field
There’s something about Bobby Coombs field that feels right. It feels like New England baseball. It’s almost as if they used this park to model every other baseball park in the region. This goes both ways, however, because you sort of expect Williams to blow you away. There are plenty of fields out there of similar quality, so I thought the Ephs would do better. I don’t want to knock them too hard though – this is a well taken care of playing surface with solid dugouts and a nice surrounding area. Playing a game at Williams feels like the truest form of baseball – sunny skies, Rainbow flip flops, and EDM echoing across campus.
- Tufts
Huskins Field
Tufts has another very respectable, grass field. The solid fence as opposed to chain link makes the field seem enclosed, giving it more of a big time feel. Saturdays can be a lot of fun for Jumbo fans when their beloved lacrosse team has game just outside the left field fence during a home game for the baseball team. Those days things can get really loud on campus, only aided by the train that rolls past right field from time to time – a unique quirk that can only be found in Medford.
- Wesleyan
Dresser Diamond at Andrus Field
I think this one might cause the most controversy of any on the list. Dresser Diamond is average at best and they don’t even have dugouts. Or a real backstop. Not a great look. What they do have is the oldest continuously used field in the United States, and an AMAZING location. You can’t go anywhere on campus without walking by Andrus Field, and as a result the Cardinals actually lead the nation in attendance*. The school’s Gothic architecture adds a beautiful backdrop, and there are tons of great viewing spots for fans. Watch out for people on Foss Hill because it’s known to get packed, especially if you’re tasked with playing Wesleyan on Zonker Harris Day.
*They must count literally anyone in the vicinity as a spectator because there’s no way Wesleyan has the highest attendance in the country.
Editor’s Note: I get it, Wesleyan’s field is the oldest baseball field in the nation and can’t be modified. But no dugouts? Really? It’s not a fun place to play when it’s freezing and windy on an early April afternoon.
- Amherst
Memorial Field
This is about as nice a grass field as they come. Memorial Field is incredibly well kept with a terrific playing surface. The brick backstop and dugouts go perfectly with their campus, and the hill along the left field line is a great spot for fans. This is one of the most beautiful fields in the conference. At this point it’s only a question of whether the Mammoths decide to follow the movement and get artificial turf, or keep their already gorgeous field. Perhaps it’s time for a change in Western Mass since Amherst hasn’t appeared in the NCAA Tournament since they were known as the now-forbidden Lord Jeffs.
Real contenders…
- Colby
Coombs Field
Obviously the three schools with turf fields are going to make up the top three on this list, so let’s break it down. Colby’s turf facility is very nice – enough so that the NESCAC decided to host last year’s conference tournament there. Unfortunately, this is a tournament they’ve never appeared in, so hopefully the field draws enough interest to turn the ship around in Waterville. Really the only reason that they fall below Hamilton is that their turf is a year older with an extra year’s worth of wear and tear. Overall, an excellent field.
- Hamilton
Loop Road Baseball Complex
Hamilton’s got another beautiful turf facility, only in its second year of use. Again, this complex really isn’t much different from Colby’s; it’s simply one year newer. I appreciate when schools match the dugout architecture with their school, so I think the Continentals made the right choice here. My guess is that being in New York puts you out of contention to host the tournament for a conference that has “New England” in the title, but you never know because this is a beautiful ballpark.
- Trinity
Murren Family Field/DiBenedetto Stadium
What a shocker. The Bantams have the nicest baseball field in the ‘CAC. This should go nicely alongside the nicest football field in the ‘CAC. Not only is Murren Family Field at DiBenedetto Stadium the best in the conference, this is one of the nicest collegiate ball parks in New England regardless of division. The stadium seating looking out at the Hartford skyline is a remarkable backdrop for a brand new, pristine turf field. The logo in center field is a really cool touch and having “NESCAC” painted along each foul line is a ridiculously classy move. This is the picture perfect site for the NESCAC tournament, and I can’t see anyone getting a nicer field than the one in West Hartford for a very long time.