Amherst College Mammoths
Head Coach: J.P. Pyne, 1st Season
Projected NESCAC Record: 8-4
Key Losses:
OF Ariel Kenney (.362, 4 HRs, 25 RBI)
IF Harry Roberson (.302, 27 RBI, 38 H)
IF Max Steinhorn (.365, 1 HR, 20 RBI)
LHP Sam Schneider (59.2 IP, 4-2, 2.56 ERA)
Coach Hamm (9 years, 221-113 record)
Key Returners:
OF Joseph Palmo ’21 (.314, 43 H, 15 RBI)
C Severino Simeone ’20 (.243, 2 HR, 17 RBI, 11 runners caught stealing)
IF Nick Nardone (.280, 2 HR, 25 RBI)
RHP Andrew Ferrero (57.0 IP, 4-3, 2.21 ERA)
Biggest Series: Home vs. Middlebury, April 19th-20th
Realistically, this division is 3 teams—Amherst, Wesleyan, and Middlebury—competing for 2 playoff spots. Amherst should have the talent and experience to handle Williams and Hamilton relatively easily (I like that Amherst gets Williams early in the year before a young Ephs team
gets to figure it all out), and whoever comes out on top in their series vs. Wesleyan, it won’t be a sweep. If Amherst can win this series vs. Midd, either 2-1 or 3-0, they should be a lock for the postseason.
Everything Else
Despite being the reigning NESCAC champions, the Mammoths unfortunately have more questions than answers coming into this season. Losing three all-league players and the ace of your rotation will always bring some uncertainty, Amherst had to conduct a coaching search as well this summer. J.P Pyne takes over the program from Clark University after previous HC of nine years Brian Hamm departed for the same position at Eastern Connecticut State. While players undoubtedly win games, it will be interesting to see what kind of effect is felt with a first-year head coach. Joseph Palmo ’21 has already begun to fill the void that first team all-leaguer Ariel Kenney left behind in the outfield, garnering the most recent NESCAC Player of the Week award. If 3B Nick Nardone ’20 and C Seve Simeone ’20 can do the same for Harry Roberson and Max Steinhorn in the infield, Amherst will have a chance to repeat as champions.
Wesleyan University Cardinals
Head Coach: Mark Woodworth, 18th Season
Projected NESCAC Record: 8-4
Key Losses:
OF Matt Jeye (.347, 1 HR, 36 RBI)
Key Returners:
OF Alex Cappitelli ’20 (.367, 2 HR, 34 RBI)
OF Danny Rose ‘20 (.361, 17 XBH, 24 RBI)
LHP Kelvin Sosa ’21 (46.2 IP, 3.09 ERA, 9.5 K/9)
LHP Mike McCaffrey (53.0 IP, 5.60 ERA, 9.7 K/9)
Biggest Series: Away @ Amherst, March 29th-30th
While I think Wesleyan is the best team in this division on paper, that isn’t where the games are played. McCaffrey and Sosa’s pitching performances (see below) in the opening series against a Little Three rival will tell Cardinal fans just how much confidence they can have in this team. While it is obviously a matchup between the top teams in the division and has playoff ramifications, it is more so just a great opportunity to see if the talent in Middletown will come to play this year.
Everything Else
Wesleyan certainly seems to be the favorite in this division this year. They return 78.4% of their innings pitched from last year’s staff, as well as some of their top guys in the field, namely junior outfielders Alex Cappitelli and Danny Rose. But this team’s season rests on the shoulders of lefties Mike McCaffrey ’19 and Kelvin Sosa ’21. McCaffrey never came close to finding his form last year, someone who many thought had a chance to be the Pitcher of the Year in the NESCAC. The reason for that is because we have all seen McCaffrey has the stuff to dominate in this league, evidenced by his league leading 57 strikeouts. But he also led the league in walks, with 48. In fact, McCaffrey was joined by the aforementioned Kelvin Sosa (4th-26) near the top of the walks leaderboard. If their top pitchers can throw strikes, they’ll win the division going away. But if their early season results are any indicator (55 Ks to 51 BB), it’s going to be a grind.
Middlebury College Panthers
Head Coach: Mike Leonard, 3rd Season
Projected NESCAC Record: 6-6
Key Losses:
P Robert Erickson (48.2 IP, 3-3, 3.51 ERA)
Key Returners:
RHP Colby Morris ’19 (64.1 IP, 5-4, 1.68 ERA)
IF Justin Han ’20 (.369 AVG, .528 OBP, 22 SB)
IF Brooks Carroll ’20 (.963 FP, 7 2B, 17 RBI)
IF Hayden Smith ’20 (.364, 36 H, 22 RBI)
Biggest Series: Away @ Williams, April 12th-13th
Anyone who has played in this league or followed it, in any sport, knows the importance of winning games against teams you’re better than. The regular season is always decided by the top teams matching up against each other, but you cannot handicap yourself by losing to lesser opponents. Middlebury closes the season with series’ at Amherst and home to Wesleyan, but they cannot come into those games at 3-3 or probably even 4-2. They need to win this series against Williams, and probably win it handily.
Everything Else
The Panthers took another step towards becoming a NESCAC contender, coming just short in a last gasp run at the NESCAC playoffs. They return the reigning Pitcher of Year in righty Colby Morris ’19, and a stacked infield. In order to take the next step up they need to find a way to score some runs, namely in the power department. They were 4th in the league in runs last season but only 7th with just 9 home runs. They are clearly great at hitting for contact and hitting for average, but they need some more star power if they are to steal a few games when the bats go cold or when they run into a good pitcher.
Williams College Ephs
Head Coach: Bill Barrale, 12th Season
Projected NESCAC Record: 6-6
Key Losses:
IF Jack Roberts (.287, 1 HR, 21 RBI)
C Adam Dulsky (.313, 1 HR, 16 RBI)
Key Returners:
OF Mike Stamas ’20 (.321, 1 HR, 13 RBI)
LHP John Lamont ’20 (40.0 IP, 4-1, 1.80 ERA) –in 2017
IF Kellen Hatheway ’19 (.228, 2 HR, 11 RBI)
Biggest Series: Home vs. Amherst April 5th-6th
Not only because it’s one of the biggest rivalries in all of collegiate athletics, but this series will be huge for the Ephs as it is their opener in divisional play. I think this is going to be a year of ups and downs for Williams, a young and unproven team riding the momentum of a long season. If they get smoked in three games, they might not recover the rest of the way, but if they are competitive in every game and even manage to take 1 or 2 off of their archrivals, it could boost their confidence for the rest of the season.
Everything Else
2018 was nothing but bad luck for the Ephs. Star pitcher Johnny Lamont ’20 missed his entire sophomore campaign, decimating an already bare cabinet of arms in Williamstown. Freshman IF Erik Pappas had been a bright spot in the lineup, hitting .415 before going down with a season ending injury after 15 games. There is certainly talent on this roster, however. IF Kellen Hatheway ’19 didn’t have the junior season he was hoping to after terrific freshman and sophomore years, but absolutely has First-Team potential. This team is probably still a year or two away, but if they can stay healthy this year, there should be some bright spots and building blocks.
Hamilton College Continentals
Head Coach: Tim Byrnes, 12th Season
Projected NESCAC Record: 2-10
Key Losses:
None
Key Returners:
IF Matt Zaffino ’21 (.359, 3 HR, 22 RBI)
IF Jarrett Lee ’21 (.305, 29 H, 13 RBI
Biggest Series: Home vs. Williams, April 26th-27th
Hamilton plays Middlebury, Wesleyan, and Amherst in that order before their divisional finale vs. Williams. Quite frankly, 2 or more wins out of those 9 would be a win for the Continentals. Their performance against their next most equal division opponent in Williams to close out the season will, rightly or wrongly, determine how Hamilton should feel about their season.
Everything Else
Hamilton are in a peculiar spot this season. They went 4-8 at the bottom of the NESCAC West but they return just about everyone. However, you’ll notice there are only two names listed as “key” returners. They return everyone, but those returners were not amongst the league’s top producers, save for Rookie of the Year Matt Zaffino, who has Player of the Year talent. This might be a good team this year, but they have Amherst, Wesleyan, and Middlebury on their schedule. Their record is going to reflect that.
